It finally happened. On their 12th album, The Hip have lost their edge.
When Canada’s most literate major-label outfit declares We Are the Same, you might expect more of the cryptic, driving rock they built their rabid fan base and two-decade career on. Instead, they delve deep into the mediocrity that was hinted at on their last outing — the Bob Rock-produced World Container. Rock is back again, leading long-time listeners to wonder if he is out to sabotage The Hip, just like he did Metallica.
It’s not all his fault, though. You might be able to pin the syrupy string arrangements and crappy trumpet solos on him, but even the band’s frontman and poet laureate Gord Downey is losing his grip. His vocals have a wonderful confidence, but his lyrics lack the maturity and enigmatic charm that set The Hip apart from all the other bar bands that have followed in their footsteps. With his bandmates sounding like over-produced session players putting an emphasis on maudlin MOR acoustic roots rock, We Are the Same sounds more like The Eagles than The Tragically Hip. That’s not just bad; it’s unforgivable.
Comments: 2
Melly Mel wrote:
I saw them play at an unbelievable festival in Gimli MB called Sunfest !! The first year it was an all Canadian lineup and not well known, so the crowd was perfect. Over the years, I have seen them play more times that I can recall at the moment. Outdoor, indoor, large venue, intimate venue, and house parties.
I am a huge fan...however, I WILL NEVER GO SEE THEM AGAIN .
I was saddened by the new album and honestly hate the new songs. And saw them a few years ago at the U of C. Brutal performance, knowing what I have seen them do, they have not just fallen, but rolled down the hill.
Well written review, and I completely agreed with every word.
on May 22nd, 2009 at 6:55pm Report Abuse
bohunk wrote:
Loved Gord D. in One Week. What was up with the Steam Whistle product placement, though?
Twix. Two chocolate bars in one!
on May 22nd, 2009 at 7:56pm Report Abuse
Post comment: (Login or Register)