Dark beers are all treat and no trick

Distilling the troubling myths of delicious, sinister brews

Halloween is here and the evil beer-marketing demons from Ireland are telling us to embrace the dark side of beer, because dark is scary. I love all 30-plus styles of dark beer, but what scare me are the terrifying myths about the dark beer families.

Let’s drive a big stake through the heart of these sinister lies right now.

Dark beer is stronger: Budweiser is almost transparent and ghostly, but it’s a ghastly five per cent alcohol that might scare some, while the most common of wicked darks, Guinness, terrifies us at 4.1 per cent. Samuel Adams’s Utopias, one of the world’s strongest and most expensive beers, has a brain-numbing effect at 25 per cent, but it’s almost the same colour as Kokanee Gold (five per cent). Now that’s scary.

Dark beer is heavier: What zombie thought this up? Dark roast coffee isn’t heavier than light roast coffee and Coke isn’t heavier than Sprite. Once one understands the way beer is made, colour has nothing to do with how heavy it is. The brain thinks it’s devil’s food cake in a glass because it is dark, so most run away like teenagers in a horror movie, but the truth is that most beers are made of similar ratios of 90 per cent pale malt and 10 per cent character malt. The colour of character malts comes from a kilning process very similar to roasting coffee. The longer malt is kilned, the more the demon seeds’ flavours transform from toasty, to chocolaty, to dark, roasty flavours. This process draws a very strong parallel to the roastiness in all the sinful shades of coffee.

The weight of a beer in your mouth depends on how much unfermented sugars are still in the finished product — what brewers refer to as the degree of attenuation. It’s about how much sugar the gluttonous yeasts eat and secrete before eating themselves to death and exploding. Once again, no matter the colour of the beer, the brewer controls the residual sugar levels. Guinness has 125 calories per 12-ounce serving, versus Bud Light, which has 148. Although shocking, this knowledge is not as blood-curdling as the thought of having to drink either brew.

Dark beers are more bitter: As scary as the eternal hell of the twisted bitter beer face is, this terrible myth holds a pinch of truth. Very dark roasts add some bitterness to the brew, but it’s hops, the devil’s bud, that is the main bittering agent in beer. A beer is only as bitter as the sorcerer makes it, no matter the shade. The magical spell cast on the tongue by any great beer is the wrestling match between good and evil or, in this case, the sweetness and bitterness that one experiences while drinking it.

Since I may have scared some of you this Halloween, I’ll let you in on a little secret: dark beers are scared too — of being served too cold. The warmer these little devils get, the more they expose their souls and cast their dark magic on you. Please ask the warlock or witch at your favourite potion shop about all the dark magic they stock, but remember: Once you go black, you may never go back.

 


Comments: 4

el Gordo wrote:

Mike, I am a little shocked that you find "the thought of having to drink either" Bud Light or Guinness equally blood curdling. Although we cannot enjoy Guinness at it's best here in Canada, I still think a well presented pint of Guinness in one of our local Irish pubs is a treat.

You also make a blanket statement about black beers being better the warmer they get. While I would agree that most beer is served way too cold in this country, I do feel that a crisp German black lager such as Kostritzer Schwarzbier (recommended serving temperature 46 F) drinks well at a far cooler temperature than, say, a dense and complex Russian Imperial Stout such as Old Rasputin (recommended serving temperature 55 F) though both are ink black. When it comes to determining serving temperature I feel that style is a far more important consideration than colour.

on Oct 28th, 2010 at 2:09pm Report Abuse

Hoser wrote:

Thanks el Gordo

Sorry you took things literally, the article was meant to be fun and educational. I think the goal was accomplished without beating one down with hard facts and making the article boring.

You may have a hard time finding Kostritzer Schwarzbier it hasn't been in this market in years. For dark lagers Paddock Wood's Black, Brew Brother's Black Pilsner for a dunkle lagers, Les Trois Mousquestaires or Celebrator for dopplebocks would be my recommendations. (there are probably more that I can't remember at this time)

As for your observations of lager and ale serving temperatures they are almost correct. 48 for a lager 55 for an ale is what most books recommend. I said warmer not a temperature, North American's drink beer to cold in general.

As for the Guinness glad you enjoy it but I would rather drink water. I don't like any beer poured on Nitrogen whether served in Ireland or at an Irish pub in Calgary. Nitrogen strips a beer of flavour. Some places around town have Mill Street Porter, served on Aligal. Try back to back pints of Guinness and Mill Street's Porter and you will see what I am talking about.

Thank you for you input and glad you hear you aren't afraid of the dark!

on Oct 28th, 2010 at 4:04pm Report Abuse

el Gordo wrote:

Well, Mike, I really wasn't looking for a pissing contest, but since this is about beer...

You say that my observations of lager and ale serving temperatures are almost correct (how gracious) and then say 48 for lager and 55 for ale is what is recommended by most books. I was merely suggesting temperatures for two specific beers (as far as I know, those temperatures come directly from the brewers). Upon a quick flip through "1001 Beers You Must Taste Before You Die" I found a range of recommended temperatures for lagers that ran from a low of 36 F for some to a high of 61 F for one. As for ales, the gamut ran from 37 F to 64 F. To suggest that there is one temperature for lagers and another for ales is ludicrous. What books are you reading?

Also, of course there are countless dark beers that are superior to nitrogen driven Guinness. It is not even close to my favorite stout. But if I were in a pub and my choices were Bud Light and Guinness I wouldn't hesitate for a second.

To be honest, for my personal taste, I usually drink my beers, especially ales, a fair bit warmer than is recommended. When trying a new beer, I like to sip it slowly, allowing the temperature to continue to rise to the point where, for me, the flavour is no longer improving. For many complex ales, this is often pretty close to room temperature (I keep my place on the cool side).

And finally, if I put a pint of Guinness and a glass of water in front of you, you're telling me you'd opt for the water?! I find that hard to swallow.

on Oct 28th, 2010 at 6:37pm Report Abuse

Hoser wrote:

Great you have a copy of "1001 Beers You Must Taste Before you Die". My good friends Chuck Cook and Joris Pattyn wrote sections of that book. You are correct a Flanders Red and Southern English Brown are different beers and are best at different temperatures.

Sorry for the overview, glad you are serious about beer.



on Oct 28th, 2010 at 7:35pm Report Abuse


Post comment: (Login or Register)


All Content Copyright © Fast Forward Weekly 1995-2012

About Us Contact Us Careers Privacy Policy Terms of Use